Devices and Desires Page 33
The 6th Duke, known as the Bachelor Duke, had to pay off the considerable debts left by his parents, but became an extravagant spender himself. He transferred quantities of furniture, paintings and tapestries from his other houses to Hardwick, and carried out various improvements, including blocking up the windows at either end of the long gallery, to reduce glare. He adored the house, dining in the High Great Chamber, despite the extreme cold, and sleeping, and eventually dying, in Bess’s corner bedchamber. The Bachelor Duke was succeeded by his second cousin, who built the two-storey service wing, with bedrooms for servants, at the north end of the house.
The 6th and 7th Dukes also left huge debts, but the 8th and 9th Dukes did much to recoup them. Under the 9th Duke, extensive repairs to Hardwick’s structure and stonework (which had been badly damaged by pollution from local coal mines) were carried out, but it was his wife, Duchess Evelyn, a woman of whom Bess would have approved, who took on the task of preserving the house. After she was widowed in 1938, the Dowager Duchess came to live at Hardwick, making Bess’s rooms her own and devoting herself to the repair and restoration of Bess’s tapestries and hangings. Except for the war years, she remained at Hardwick until her death in 1960, three years after Hardwick had been given to the nation in lieu of death duties, and two years after it had been made over to the National Trust.
Acknowledgements
This book has been a long time in the making and there are many to whom I am grateful for their scholarship, help and patience. Anyone interested in Bess of Hardwick has reason to thank Alison Wiggins and her team at Glasgow University, who have collected, and made available online, Bess’s entire correspondence. Similarly, the task of deciphering early modern English has been made immeasurably easier by the work of David Durant, biographer of Bess, whose papers and transcriptions of Bess’s household and building accounts can be read at Nottingham University Library. Philip Riden has also done much painstaking research into and work on Bess’s accounts and papers, correcting a few misconceptions in the process. I’m very grateful to him for supplying articles and patiently answering questions. I feel greatly indebted to Mark Girouard for his invaluable works on Robert Smythson and Elizabethan architecture, and I thank him for conversations about Bess and Hardwick, for reading parts of the book and for correcting architectural errors.
Thanks to Dr Kate Harris, archivist at Longleat House, and to James Towe and Aidan Haley, archivists at Chatsworth. Quotations from the Thynne papers are included by permission of the Marquess of Bath, Longleat House, and from the Chatsworth archives, by kind permission of the Duke of Devonshire and the Chatsworth House trust. Also thanks to the staff at the British Library, Lambeth Palace Library, Nottingham University Library and the London Library. For permission to reproduce drawings and photographs I am grateful to those institutions credited in the list of illustrations, and to Clare Broomfield, Megan Evans, Jonathan Makepeace and Diane Naylor in particular. Many thanks to Tim Wales, for battling with the Earl of Shrewsbury’s handwriting, to John Goodall at Country Life, for talking to me about Hardwick, and to Andrew Barber at the National Trust. At Hardwick, Nigel Wright and Elena Williams kindly showed me around, answered questions and allowed me to wander about after hours. Thank you to the late Alexander Chancellor, for accompanying me on a tour of Elizabethan houses in Northamptonshire. For their hospitality at Doddington Hall, thanks to James and Clare Birch, and to Antony Jarvis, for sharing his immense knowledge of and enthusiasm for the house. For showing me Shireoaks, taking me to Worksop Manor Lodge, and conversation about Smythson, I am extremely grateful to Leo Godlewski.
I would like to thank Mary Miers, for all her help, and Rebecca Nicolson and Aurea Carpenter at Short Books, for whom I first wrote about Bess. For chat and excellent advice on Tudor matters, thanks to Jessie Childs. Also to Victoria Millar, who read an early draft and made many useful suggestions. And to Georgia Garrett, my agent. I feel lucky in my friends and family: thank you to all those who offered advice, support and good cheer along the way, including Lucy Baring, David and Emma Craigie, Miranda Creswell, Phil Eade, Alexa de Ferranti, Catherine Gibbs, Ed and Nicole Hubbard, Max and Lucas Hubbard, Caryl Hubbard, Ben Macintyre, Flora McDonnell, Adam Nicolson, Karen Richards, Ben Rogers, Sweetpea Slight, Simon and Alexa Tiffin, Daryl Weldon and Caddy Wilmot-Sitwell. I have been lucky too in my publishers. My editors – Juliet Brooke at Chatto & Windus and Jennifer Barth at Harper Collins US – waited patiently for this book and pushed me, gently, to make it better. Juliet’s successor, Charlotte Humphery, guided it through its final stages with the greatest efficiency and care. The team at Chatto – Jane Selley (copy-editor), Alison Rae (proofreader), Kris Potter (designer) and Emmy Lopes (map-drawer) did a fine job. My thanks to all of them.
Select Bibliography
Unless stated otherwise, the place of publication is London.
Books
Adshead, David, and Taylor, David A. H. B. (eds), Hardwick Hall: A Great Old Castle of Romance, New Haven, Yale, 2016
Airs, Malcolm, The Tudor and Jacobean Country House: A Building History, Stroud, Sutton, 1995
Bacon, Francis, The Essays, Macmillan, 1900
Brigden, Susan, New Worlds, Lost Worlds: The Rule of the Tudors 1485–1603, Allen Lane, 2000
Brotton, Jerry, This Orient Isle: Elizabethan England and the Islamic World, Allen Lane, 2016
Camden, William, Britannia, 1789
Childs, Jessie, God’s Traitors: Terror and Faith in Elizabethan England, Bodley Head, 2014
Collins, A. C., Historical Collections of the Noble Families of Cavendish, Holles, Vere, Harley and Ogle, Withers, 1752
Cooper, Nicholas, Houses of the Gentry, 1480–1680, New Haven & London, Yale, 1999
Cowell, Ben, ‘Hardwick Hall: An Archival Survey’, unpublished report, National Trust, 1997, Chatsworth
Crook, David, ‘Hardwick Before Bess: The Origins and Early History of the Hardwick Family and Their Estate’, Derbyshire Archaeological Journal, Vol. 107, 1987
Daybell, James, Women Letter-Writers in Tudor England, Oxford University Press, 2006
Durant, David N., Arbella Stuart: A Rival to the Queen, Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1978
Durant, David N., Bess of Hardwick: Portrait of an Elizabethan Dynast, Peter Owen, 1977
Durant, David N., The Smythson Circle: The Story of Six Great English Houses, Peter Owen, 2011
Durant, David, and Riden, Philip (eds), The Building of Hardwick Hall: Part I, The Old Hall, 1587–91, Derbyshire Record Society, Vol. IV, 1980
Durant, David, and Riden, Philip (eds), The Building of Hardwick Hall: Part II, The New Hall, 1591–98, Derbyshire Record Society, Vol. IX, 1984
Erickson, Amy Louise, Women and Property in Early Modern England, Routledge, 1993
Friedman, Alice T., House and Household in Elizabethan England: Wollaton Hall and the Willoughby Family, Chicago & London, University of Chicago, 1989
Frye, Susan, Pens and Needles: Women’s Textualities in Early Modern England, Philadelphia & London, University of Pennsylvania, 2010
Furnivall, F. J. (ed.), Harrison’s Description of England in Shakespeare’s Youth, 1877
Girouard, Mark, Elizabethan Architecture: Its Rise and Fall 1540–1640, New Haven & London, Yale, 2009
Girouard, Mark, Robert Smythson and the Elizabethan Country House, New Haven & London, Yale, 1983
Goodall, John A., Lady Anne Clifford and the Architectural Pursuit of Nobility, Yorkshire Archaeological Society, 2009
Gristwood, Sarah, Arbella: England’s Lost Queen, Bantam, 2003
Guy, John, Elizabeth: The Forgotten Years, Viking, 2016
Guy, John, My Heart is my Own: The Life of Mary Queen of Scots, Fourth Estate, 2009
Harris, Barbara J., English Aristocratic Women, 1450–1550: Marriage and Family, Property and Careers, Oxford University Press, 2002
Henderson, Paula, The Tudor House and Garden: Architecture and Landscape in the Sixteenth and Early Seventeenth Centuries, New Haven & London, Yale, 2005
Hey, David, Packmen, Carriers and Packhorse Roads: Trade and Communications in North Derbyshire and South Yorkshire, Leicester University Press, 1980
Howard, Leonard, A Collection of Letters from the Original Manuscripts, E. Withers, 1753
Howard, Maurice, The Building of Elizabethan and Jacobean England, New Haven & London, Yale, 2007
Howard, Maurice, The Early Tudor Country House: Architecture and Politics, 1490–1550, George Philip, 1987
Hunter, Joseph, A History of Hallamshire, 1869
Innocent, C. F., The Development of English Building Construction, Cambridge University Press, 1916
Ives, Eric, Lady Jane Grey: A Tudor Mystery, Wiley-Blackwell, 2009
Johnson, Nathaniel, A History of the Lives of the Earls of Shrewsbury, 7 vols, 1692–3, unpublished, Chatsworth
Jones, Norman, God and the Moneylenders: Usury and Law in Early Modern England, Oxford, Blackwell, 1989
Kettle, Pamela, Oldcotes: The Last Mansion Built by Bess of Hardwick, Cardiff, Merton Priory Press, 2000
Kiernan, David, The Derbyshire Lead Industry in the Sixteenth Century, Derbyshire Record Society, Vol. XIV, 1989
Labanoff, Prince A., Letters of Mary Stuart, 1845
Langham, Mike, and Wells, Colin, Buxton Waters: A History of Buxton the Spa, J. H. Hall & Sons, 1986
Leader, J. D., Mary Queen of Scots in Captivity, Sheffield, 1880
Levey, Santina M., An Elizabethan Inheritance: The Hardwick Hall Textiles, National Trust, 1998
Levey, Santina M., The Embroideries at Hardwick Hall: A Catalogue, National Trust, 2007
Levey, Santina M., and Thornton, Peter K. (eds), Of Household Stuff: The 1601 inventories of Bess of Hardwick, National Trust, 2001
Levy, Allison (ed.), Widowhood and Visual Culture in Early Modern Europe, Ashgate, 2003 Lisle, Leanda de, The Sisters Who Would Be Queen: The Tragedy of Mary, Katherine and Lady Jane Grey, Harper, 2008
Lisle, Leanda de, Tudor: The Family Story, Chatto & Windus, 2013
Lodge, Edmund, Illustrations of British History, Biography and Manners, 3 vols, John Chidley, 1838
Lovell, Mary S., Bess of Hardwick: First Lady of Chatsworth, Little, Brown, 2005
Newcastle, Duchess of, The Life of William Duke of Newcastle, 1906
Nichols, John, The Progresses and Public Processions of Queen Elizabeth, 1823
Nichols, John, The Progresses, Processions and Magnificent Festivities of King James I, 4 vols, 1828
Picard, Liza, Elizabeth’s London, Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 2003
Rawson, Maud, Bess of Hardwick and her Circle, Hutchinson, 1910
Read, Conyers, Lord Burghley and Queen Elizabeth, Jonathan Cape, 1960
Richardson, Walter C., History of the Court of Augmentations, 1536–54, Baton Rouge, Louisiana State University Press, 1961
Riden, Philip, ‘The Hardwicks of Hardwick Hall in the Fifteenth and Sixteenth Centuries’, Derbyshire Archaeological Journal, Vol. 130, 2010
Riden, Philip (ed.), The Household Accounts of William Cavendish, 1597–1607, Derbyshire Record Society, 2016
Riden, Philip, ‘Sir William Cavendish: Tudor Civil Servant and Founder of a Dynasty’, Derbyshire Archaeological Journal, Vol. CXXIX, 2009
Riden, Philip, and Edwards, David G. (eds), Essays in Derbyshire History, Derbyshire Record Society, Vol. XXX, 2006
Riden, Philip, and Fowkes, Dudley, Hardwick: A Great House and its Estate, Phillimore, 2009
Rowse, A. L., The England of Elizabeth: The Structure of Society, Macmillan, 1951
Sitwell, Sacheverell, British Architects and Craftsmen, Stroud, B.T. Batsford, 1945
Sim, Alison, Food and Feast in Tudor England, Sutton, 1997
Skelton, R. A., and Summerson, John (eds), A Description of Maps and Architectural Drawings in the Collection made by William Cecil, The Roxburgh Club, 1971
Stallybrass, Basil, ‘Bess of Hardwick’s Buildings and Building Accounts’, Archaeologia, Vol. LXIV, 1913
Starkey, David, Elizabeth: Apprenticeship, Chatto & Windus, 2000
Steen, Sara Jayne (ed.), The Letters of Lady Arbella Stuart, Oxford University Press, 1994
Stone, Lawrence, The Crisis of the Aristocracy, 1558–1641, Oxford University Press, 1965
Stone, Lawrence, Family and Fortune: Studies in Aristocratic Finance in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries, Oxford University Press, 1973
Stone, Lawrence, The Family, Sex and Marriage in England, 1500–1800, Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1977
Strachey, Lytton, Elizabeth and Essex, Chatto & Windus, 1929
Strickland, Agnes, Letters of Mary Queen of Scots, 2 vols, 1844
Summerson, John, Architecture in Britain 1530–1830, Penguin, 1963
Summerson, John, ‘The Building of Theobalds, 1564–85’, Archaeologia, Vol. XCVII, 1959, pp. 107–126
Thurley, Simon, The Royal Palaces of Tudor England: Architecture and Court Life, 1460–1547, New Haven & London, Yale, 1993
Thurley, Simon, Somerset House: The Palace of England’s Queens, 1551–1692, London Topographical Society, No. 168, 2009.
‘The Tresham Papers, belonging to T. B. Clarke-Thornhill Esq.’, HMC 55: Report on Manuscripts in Various Collections, Vol. III, 1904
Weir, Alison, Elizabeth the Queen, Jonathan Cape, 1998
Wells-Cole, Anthony, Art and Decoration in Elizabethan and Jacobean England: The Influence of Continental Prints, 1558–1625, New Haven & London, Yale, 1997
White, Gillian, ‘“That whyche ys nedefoulle and nesesary”: The Nature and Purpose of the Original Furnishings and Decoration of Hardwick Hall Derbyshire’, unpublished PhD thesis, University of Warwick, 2005
Whitelock, Anna, Elizabeth’s Bedfellows, Bloomsbury, 2013
Wigfull, J. R., ‘Extracts from the Notebook of William Dickenson’, Transactions of the Hunter Archaeological Society, Vol. II, 1921
Wigfull, J. R., ‘House Building in Queen Elizabeth’s Days’, Transactions of the Hunter Archaeological Society, Vol. III, 1925
Williams, E. C., Bess of Hardwick, Longman, 1959
Worsley, Lucy, Hardwick Old Hall, English Heritage, 1998
Notes on Sources
All letters to and from Bess can be viewed online: http://www.bessofhardwick.org, Bess of Hardwick’s Letters: The Complete Correspondence, c.1550–1608, ed. Alison Wiggins, Alan Bryson, Daniel Starza Smith, Anke Timmermann and Graham Williams, University of Glasgow, web development by Katherine Rogers, University of Sheffield Humanities Research Institute (April 2013).
Transcriptions of Bess’s household and building accounts, made by David Durant, are held at Nottingham University Library (David Durant Papers).
The Folger Shakespeare Library, Washington DC, holds the Cavendish-Talbot MSS (X.d. 428), the account book of Sir William and Lady Cavendish, 1548–50, (X.d. 486) and Edward Whalley’s London account book, 9 September 1589–12 July 1592 (V.b. 308).
The Talbot and Shrewsbury MSS are in Lambeth Palace Library.
The Devonshire MSS are at Chatsworth.
The Thynne Papers and the Longleat building accounts are at Longleat. The Thynne Papers are also on microfilm in the British Library.
The Cecil Papers, Hatfield House, are available online in the British Library.
Abbreviations
BHL Bess of Hardwick’s Letters: The Complete Correspondence, c. 1550–1608
BL British Library
CP Cecil Papers
CSP Domestic Calendar of State Papers, Domestic
CSP Scotland Calendar of State Papers relating to Scotland
HMC Historical Manuscripts Commission
L&P Letters and Papers Foreign and Domestic, Henry VIII
LPL Lambeth Palace Library
TNA The National Archives
Notes
Introduction
1Furnivall (ed.), Vol. I, p.130.
2‘Of Building’, Bacon, p.111.
3Quoted in Summerson, Architecture in Britain, p.38.
4Quoted in Stone, Family, Sex and Marria
ge, p.198.
5Goodall.
6Howard, Building of Elizabethan and Jacobean England, pp.159–61.
7Strachey, p.10.
8Hunter, p.84
9Lodge, Vol. I, p.xvii.
Prologue: Hardwick Hall, 1590
1Durant and Riden (eds), Building of Hardwick Hall: Part I, p.114.
2Durant, Smythson Circle, p.138.
1. Derbyshire Beginnings
1For a discussion of Bess’s birth date, see Riden, ‘Hardwicks of Hardwick Hall’, p.150.
2TNA E 150/743/8.
3Crook, ‘Hardwick Before Bess’, pp.41–54.
4Hey, p.12.
5Levey and Thornton (eds), p.53.
6For libraries at Hardwick, see Adshead and Taylor (eds), pp.177–86.
7TNA E 150/743/8.
8Riden, ‘Hardwicks of Hardwick Hall’, p.157.
9Ibid., pp.153 and 155.
10Thurley, p.39.
11Furnivall (ed.), Vol. II, p.268.
12Girouard, Elizabethan Architecture, p.25.
13Airs, p.72.
14Riden, ‘Hardwicks of Hardwick Hall’, p.154.
15Johnson, Vol. V, p.259.
16Riden, ‘Hardwicks of Hardwick Hall’, p.152.
17TNA CI/1101/17.